Skip to content
Krantz & Polak Resolve
en

Explainer Your rights · 5 min by Krantz & Polak

You are entitled to your own expert (counter-expertise)

The insurer's expert works for the insurer. You may put your own independent specialist opposite them.

After a loss, your insurer often promptly sends its own loss adjuster. That adjuster is knowledgeable, but works on the instructions of — and is paid by — the insurer. You may put your own expert opposite them: the counter-expert.

What does a counter-expert do?

  • Assesses the loss afresh, independently and in full.
  • Checks the insurer’s report for inaccuracies and missed items.
  • Translates your loss into the terms of the policy conditions.
  • Conducts the discussions with the insurer’s expert on your behalf.

Our advice for damage to your home or business premises

In the event of storm, water, fire, smoke or soot damage to a home or business premises, our advice is always to engage your own expert. The counter-expert handles the procedural side of the settlement with the insurer and prevents miscommunication about the circumstances, the question of fault and the determination of the amount of the loss — the items to be paid out.

It is about balance, not conflict

A counter-expertise is not about picking a fight. It ensures that your interests, too, are put on the table with the same expertise and in the same language. In practice, the discussions often run all the more smoothly as a result.

Good to know — You are entirely free in your choice of expert. An insurer may not make NIVRE registration a condition: the Court of Appeal of The Hague ruled in 2020 (affirmed by the Dutch Supreme Court in 2022) that such a requirement is unlawful. Moreover, NIVRE was co-founded by insurers and is therefore not an independent quality mark. What counts is demonstrable expertise and genuine independence from insurers.

When is your own expert a wise choice?

Not for every minor claim — but in these situations your own counter-expert almost always achieves a better and fairer outcome:

  • The damage is substantial (guideline: from around € 5,000).
  • The insurer doubts your account or accuses you of intent, negligence or fraud.
  • The cause or circumstances are unclear — often with fire or water damage.
  • An exclusion or deduction is invoked that you do not understand.
  • There is underinsurance, or discussion about current value and depreciation.
  • There is business interruption loss on top of the damage to property or contents.
  • Your claim has been (partly) rejected.
  • Before you sign — or before the insurer's expert records the damage one-sidedly.

Not sure whether it makes sense in your case? A first check costs nothing.

Also relevant

Just had damage?

Call us or report your claim online. We usually respond within 24 hours.

Call WhatsApp Report